Ww1 and Female Suffrage: Help or Hindered?

In: Historical Events

Submitted By HannahDougherty
Words 1373
Pages 6
(b) Do you agree with the view that the First World War hindered rather than helped the case of female suffrage? [40 Marks]

In the sources presented, there are contrasting views as to whether the First World War helped or hindered the cause of female suffrage.
On the one hand, there were many people who argued that because women had worked so relentlessly during the war, it would be impossible to deny them the vote. This is argued in source 4 in which Asquith states it would be “impossible to withhold from women the power and the right of making their voices heard”, implying that women’s work and effort throughout the war should be recognised and their deeds should not simply be ‘swept under the table’, so to say. During the war some 4 million women were employed in jobs previously done by men, whether this is from munitions factories and land girls, to the extent of secretarial and administration work following the invention of the typewriter and telephone. What is unusual about source 4, is the individual this source has come from. Asquith was a Liberal MP most infamous in fact, for his anti-female enfranchisement views. Now, post war Asquith does change his mind on the issue and goes onto support female suffrage, however at this point he was still believed to be against the cause. Perhaps Asquith has given this speech with the intention of regaining support after losing the Prime Minister post to David Lloyd George in 1916 during the coalition government, therefore this source although somewhat accurate, provides less weight for the argument the war helped the cause of women’s suffrage.

However, source 6 challenges source 4 and presents the idea that in fact the war actually “obstructed votes for women” as according to this source it was seen that although women were taking over men’s previous jobs and even working within the armed forces themselves, they were…...

Similar Documents

Woman's Suffrage

...Riley Flynn Woman’s Suffrage Now days when you turn eighteen in the United States. you can vote in the election but that was not always true for woman. Before 1920 woman were not allowed to vote only men could. It all began in 1848, at the first woman’s rights convention in New York, and didn’t end until 1920 when the 19th amendment, which gave women the right to vote, was finally ratified and became a law on August 26, 1920. Many brave woman and organizations fought for the right to be considered equal to men. Organizations such as NWSA, founded by Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and AWSA, founded by Lucy Stone and Henry Blackwell. These people, as well as many others, took a stand so that woman could have the rights that they do today, the right to vote. Woman’s suffrage was one of the most influential things in history because it allowed men and woman to be treated as equals, and without it, America would not be where it is today. During World War One women stepped up their role and took on the men’s jobs while they were fighting, without them, the country would not have survived. Woman who campaigned for the vote stopped their radical actions to aid Britain in a time of need. Women assisted by going to special training camps to become doctors, they helped in food production, factories, and even worked in the fields planting and harvesting doing all the things men would have been responsible for before the war. Women put their feelings aside, stepped...

Words: 978 - Pages: 4

Ww1 Questions

...History WW1 Questions 1) What were the war plans? In the First World War Germany and France had both made plans for attack. Germany had the ‘Schlieffen Plan’ and the French had ‘Plan 17’. The ‘Schlieffen Plan’ was simple, yet risky. The plan was to send German soldiers through Belgium and into France very quickly. The Germans were supposed to swoop around France and take the French army by surprise. This as time tells did not work out for the Germans. The French also had a plan called ‘Plan 17’. This was to launch a direct attack upon Germany through Alsace-Lorraine. On the 20th of August the German forces defending the frontier cut the attacking French troops to shreds using their artillery. The French lost 200,000 men within only 12 days and decided to abort ‘Plan 17’. 2) Explain the flaws in the initial plans There were many flaws in both the ‘Schlieffen Plan’ and ‘Plan 17’. The ‘Schlieffen Plan’ was a very flawed plan mainly because it was revised multiple times making it weaker and weaker. The ‘Schlieffen Plan’ was continuously revised and the wing to go through Belgium was considerably reduced in size so it can then protect Germany. This then meant that if Belgium gave any resilience then their numbers could then be further reduced. Unfortunately for the Germans luck was not on their side and Belgium held them back long enough for England to arrive and help them. This then made Germans army massively reduced and their plan was starting to crumble. They......

Words: 815 - Pages: 4

Suffrage Movement

...The term “Suffrage” is referred to as the right to vote. Therefore women’s suffrage is the right of women to vote. The women suffrage movement was the struggle to get the same right to vote as men. It lasted at least seventy years. The first formal convention was the Seneca Falls Convention in Seneca Falls, New York. It was organized in 1848, after women became aware of their unequal status in society, particularly their lack of suffrage. Elizabeth Stanton and Lucretia Mott launched the first woman suffrage movement in the United States. Before the 19th Century, people thought that property owners had the strongest interest in good government so they were therefore qualified to make the right decisions. So during the colonial period, voting was restricted to white adult males who owned property. Therefore in the early 19th Century when social changes occurred for women and the idea of equality came along with it, women all over the United States decided to stage the women right movements. By then, more women were receiving education. Women also began to participate in reform movements and take increased interest in politics. Women and men began to question why women were not also allowed to vote. Supporters of this drive were called suffragists. Women suffrage became the popular topic for discussion. Women believed that if they were allowed to vote they would be able to correct the social injustice rendered to them. They would be able to use it to gain other rights. ......

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

How Has Ww1 Been Remembered?

...History Assessment: How Has WW1 Been Remembered? WW1 has, and always will be seen as one, if not the most significant war in all of history. One of the reasons for it being such a tragic event was that it was deemed at the time to have been ‘the war to end all wars,’ however that tragically was not the case. World War One was caused by several contributing factors, which resulted on Britain declaring war on Germany. They are: The alliance system, Imperialism, The Naval Race, The Schlieffen Plan and finally, the assassination of Franz Ferdinand. 1. The alliance system: At the end of the 19th century, alliances were made between countries. The alliances were formed so that if any of the countries in an alliance went to war, the other countries would have to help the country that had gone to war. At this point, there were two major alliances. The first consisted of Germany, Austro-Hungary and Italy, named the Triple Alliance. The other, made up of Britain, France and Russia, was named the Triple Entente. As these alliances were formed, there became immediate friction between the two alliances, as each one tried to overpower the other. 2. Imperialism: At that time, Kaiser, as well as the rest of Germany wanted a vast empire, like the British. Although they had the money as well as the resources, they had nothing to show for it. Kaiser wanted Germany to have access to raw materials and new markets. He also wanted to give Germany more respect. This angered Britain as Germany......

Words: 2262 - Pages: 10

Universal Adult Suffrage

...The campaign for suffrage - a historical background Today, all British citizens over the age of eighteen share a fundamental human right: the right to vote and to have a voice in the democratic process. But this right is only the result of a hard fought battle. The suffrage campaigners of the nineteenth and early twentieth century struggled against opposition from both parliament and the general public to eventually gain the vote for the entire British population in 1928. ------------------------------------------------- Who took part in the campaign? The first women's suffrage bill came before parliament in 1870. Soon after its defeat, in 1897, various local and national suffrage organisations came together under the banner of the National Union of Women's Suffrage Societies (NUWSS) specifically to campaign for the vote for women on the same terms 'it is or may be granted to men'. The NUWSS was constitutional in its approach, preferring to lobby parliament with petitions and hold public meetings. In contrast, the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU), formed in 1903, took a more militant view. Almost immediately, it characterised its campaign with violent and disruptive actions and events. Together, these two organisations dominated the campaign for women's suffrage and were run by key figures such as the Pankhurstsand Millicent Fawcett. However, there were other organisations prominent in the campaign, including the Women's Freedom League (WFL). These groups were......

Words: 16345 - Pages: 66

Enrance of Ww1

...late April of 1917, the Allies sent delegates to America to try and figure out what the U.S. role in the campaign would be. The two Allies, however, did not have a set plan of agreement on how the Americans were to help out. Neither of the Allies believed in the Americans’ ability to train forces to the level needed in that short amount of time. The French wanted to send an American division to France to symbolize the Americans participation (James A. Henretta, 2012). The British also had its expectation and plans. The British however wanted 500,000 Americans to ship to England, where they would be trained, equipped, and incorporated into the British Army. The bringing of Americans into the French and British units was a much more feasible option. It was easier to attach forces to the French and British units than it would have been to build a new force from scratch for many reasons, the main one was limited time and limited shipping of the forces across the ocean. Although it was a great idea, many Americans did not accept the fact they would serve under the British, which America had worked so hard in the past to defeat. With that being said, President Wilson rejected the British proposal but did agree to send a division to France immediately. With the help of Marshal Jofree, and Army planners, the organization of four regiments of 17,700 men, 11,000 being infantrymen began. During the same time that the division being sent to France was being organized, Maj. Gen.......

Words: 1307 - Pages: 6

Women's Suffrage Movement

...The Suffrage Movement in the Bahamas had its origins in the emerging Black middle-class of the "over-the-hill" area of Nassau. Notable women such as Dame Doris Johnson, Mary Ingraham, Eugenia Lockhart, Mabel Walker and Georgianna Symonette has made countless triumphs toward the equal rights of all women in the Bahamas in The Women’s Suffrage Movement. This movement’s main purpose was to ensure that all women would have a right to practice the franchise. Sir Randol Fawkes described the struggle for the enfranchisement of women in his book, “The Faith That Moved the Mountain”. where he states, "More than half of the adult population of the Bahamas - the women - still remained voteless. In 1958, they lagged far behind their male counterparts in the field of human rights. The chief roadblocks to full citizenship for Bahamian women were the traditional attitudes of men and women towards their respective roles in society, the lack of equal training and education, vocational guidance and counseling in the school, the division of the labour market into traditionally male and female sectors, and lack of child-care facilities for working mothers". Sir Randol detailed other disadvantages women faced including the inheritance law of primogeniture and the inadequate maintenance laws for child support. However, this is not the only thing that resulted in the hard work of the women apart of this movement. In fact, even the amount of times you could have voted and the men’s vote was......

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Womens Suffrage Movement

...Women’s Suffrage Movement David Mondor U.S. History 1865 to 1945 Paul Sadler February 19, 2005 Abstract The Women’s Suffrage Movement can trace its roots, back to Anne Hutchinson’s conviction and expulsion in 1637 for sedition in Massachusetts. This movement has had many achievements, disappointments, and internal disagreements, throughout its history, the right to vote given, then taken away, many times before it became enshrined in the United States Constitution. Through ratification by 36 states of the Nineteenth Amendment in 1920, women finally had the same rights as men, the right to be considered citizens and vote, the right to be considered equal to men. This struggle for equality and voting rights we discuss in this paper. Women’s Suffrage Movement Women’s Suffrage in America began in 1637 when Anne Hutchinson dared to defy church leaders, with her thoughts on religion. This contemptuous display of women’s rights at a time when women were considered the property of men landed Anne, before a tribunal of men. They convicted her of ‘sedition’ and expelled her from Massachusetts’s colony. Mary Dyer, having been the only person to stand up for Anne during her trial, was also expelled a few months later from the colony, along with her husband William. In 1652 Mary Dyer visited England for five years and during that time she joined the Society of Friends, the Quaker religion founded by George Fox. Returning to New England, Dyer headed back to the Massachusetts’s......

Words: 1873 - Pages: 8

Women Roles in Ww1

...system that help to reinforce their military. Women’s support is displayed in a variety of ways. The brave and the qualified women work alongside their male counterparts on the war front, as nurses and espionage members. While others provide support from the home front through the participation of females in the workplace and continuing to be the primary caregiver for the households and children. The importance of female involvement in The Great War lies in the significant consequences women’s participation has had subsequently. Without women’s involvement the story of the war would differ greatly. Women roles as nurses in the Great War is crucial to the support of the any nation’s militia. “During the Great War, the call for women to work for victory grew enthusiastic support.” Women felt their participation as nurses was their “contribution to the war effort.” “Nearly 80 000 nurses…” and women with first aid experience sign up to help, and those of which qualify are sent to work on the war front. The enthusiastic support is a result of “several motivating factors” according to Henriette Donner. Some of which include, nationalism, and the “appeal of traditional feminine work [and also] the impulse of emancipation from traditional gender roles” in the medical field. As a result of the female doctors, gender roles begin to change. Prior to the war, and the need for female doctors, “doctors …were expected to be men.” This causes tension in the war time as female doctors and...

Words: 2657 - Pages: 11

Women Suffrage

...Women suffrage in America came at a time when the nation was deeply plunged in late 1800s. Passionate suffragists; Elizabeth Cady and Susan Anthony came out strongly to form the National Woman Suffrage Association to champion for the right of women to vote and hold public office in the late nineteenth century. Though women were oppressed of their rights to vote and shut out of what was considered male dominated white collar offices, they have made great strides in various fields in the recent years and have rose to high positions of power. From the first pioneers who engineered the Nineteenth Amendment of the American Constitution thereby by granting their fellow women the right to vote and equal opportunity for pursuit of high office, women have generally made tremendous steps in ensuring change in various field from politics, office jobs, what are considered manly jobs like masonry by male chauvinists to law professions and attaining high offices in the Judicial System.   One instance where women acknowledge triumph in their pursuit in suffrage is United States Supreme Court appointing the first woman- Sandra Day O’Connor as the first woman justice in 1981. This proved their cause for equality was not all a matter of fighting a losing battle, they were making great impacts and strides in championing for the rights of women which is envisioned in future appointments of other women into the law profession. In eighteen seventy three (1873), Susan B. Anthony one of the......

Words: 2103 - Pages: 9

Women's Suffrage

...York, which is known as the Women’s Suffrage movement. This movement was a fight for equality, which could be seen as the birth of feminism. Although there were many women who led the fight for equal voice, Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony were the two primary figures of the movement. Due to California’s political climate, the movement brought great disappointment and victory for women’s rights. Disappointment turned into resolve and set forth the movement in California. Women created coalitions and started to spread their word from southern to northern California for their voice to be heard by others. The movement in California was comprised of white middle class women, but they didn’t support Asians because they feared white backlash. Soon, the eyes of the nation opened in 1911 when male voters approved women’s right vote making California the largest state to approve of women’s suffrage. Women’s suffrage in California reached started out on a high note. In 1893, early success came when the women’s suffrage bill won approval in the state legislature but it was vetoed by the governor claiming it was unconstitutional. The suffragists later took the same issue to California voters in 1896, where Populists, Prohibitionists, Republicans, and unions joined the women’s alliance to promote the issue, but it was still defeated by a majority. The Liquor Dealers League and the Democratic Party played a big role in defeating the suffrage (Silver). Not willing to admit......

Words: 1280 - Pages: 6

Women's Suffrage Movement

...class men in British society delayed women’s suffrage as for it to occur they needed the support of the ‘dominant’ and powerful group in society i.e. Men. Female attitudes towards votes for women Very few women initially supported women’s fight for suffrage. In fact many women were strongly against giving women the vote or any form of education for women or rights. As Sarah Sewell, herself opposed to women’s suffrage said, “profoundly educated women rarely make good wives or mothers.” She continued that such educated women, “seldom have much knowledge of pies and puddings . . . . nor do they enjoy the interesting work of attending to small children.” Therefore, in her and many other women’s eyes, many well off middle class women were not even capable to be a mother never mind have the vote. Queen Victoria was also greatly against women’s suffrage and described the women’s suffrage campaign as “that mad wicked folly of women’s rights.” Also, the Anti Suffrage campaign used such views as effective propaganda to persuade people that most women did not want change and were happy as they were. Politicians view towards votes for women Although most male politicians were against votes for women for chauvinistic reasons, Conservatives and Liberals were also against it for political reasons. The Conservatives were solidly against votes for women, (although former Prime Minister Disraeli had argued in favour of women’s suffrage.) The main fear of the Conservatives was......

Words: 2170 - Pages: 9

Female

...Female Rulers Erin B HUM111 November 29, 2015 History is full of powerful women who ruled over lands and won wars to protect their kingdom just the same as the powerful men in history often times better than the men. Some female rulers we know from history such as Hatshepsut who ruled over Egypt long before Cleopatra, Queen Victoria of Great Brittan, Queen Elizabeth II queen of England today and the list could go on and on. However, the two female rulers that we are going compare are Wu Zetian of china who was born in 624 A.D. and Pharaoh Cleopatra of Egypt who was born 69B.C. both was rulers of their time until their deaths. These two female rulers came from very different backgrounds but ultimately ended up on the same path to become strong rulers of their time who didn’t let nothing or no one get in their way of them keeping their kingdoms and the power that comes with it. Wu Zetian was born in 624 A.D. in Wenshui county, Shanxi Province and was the only female ruler to sit on the imperial throne. She ruled the self-proclaimed Zhou Dynasty which later became known as the Tang Dynasty from 690-705 until her death at 80 years old in 705A.D.Wu’s father Wu Shihuo was one of the meritorious chancellors of the Tang Dynasty he gave her an education by teaching her himself. Both Wu Zetian and Cleopatra was very smart starting when they was young women. Cleopatra Spoke 6 different languages Hebrew, Arabic, Latin, Eygptian, Ethiopian and Greek. Cleopatra also studied Arts,...

Words: 1532 - Pages: 7

Homefront in Ww1

...Home Front in WW1 Recruitment Volunteers * At beginning army was only small with only 250 000 men, needed 1 mill at least * Germany and enemies armies already bigger * Used propaganda * “pals battalions” large groups encouraged to sign up together as guaranteed to fight together * Half a million signed up In the first month * March 1916-2.5 mill volunteers * Downside * Families and towns lost all men * Questioned their return * Why did they join? * Posters * Get away from dull everyday life * Share in the excitement * Thought it their duty Conscription * Clear war not over by Christmas * Casualties had to be replaced, prepare from battle of the Somme November 1916 and replace thousands of dead after * Volunteers were running out – released harsh truths as people returned injured or not at all * Jan 1916 – unmarried men 18-40 * March 1916 – married men also * 1 in 3 conscripted between 1916 -18 * Meant gov had more control over work forces at home as the not conscripted were skilled workers that stayed to do jobs that couldn’t be replaced and helped the war effort Contentious objectors * Object to war for religious or humanitarian reasons * Had to convince a tribunal if they were genuine or coward * If convinced then they would help on the front line eg drive ambulances or war work at home eg mining * If rejected then sent to army, if......

Words: 945 - Pages: 4

Modern Ww1 Notes

...media showing the atrocities o Civilians at home had essentially no communication and the impacts of war on the home front became apparent and degraded over time o Morale of the troops declined over time due to abhorrent conditions in the Trenches and years of no-progress, relentless fighting during the Stalemate. The troops knew that there was no progress being made. o After two months of the war, soldiers became disillusioned. Massive casualties undermined initial enthusiasm and soldiers’ desire for the end of war was shown in the Christmas Truce of 1914 11 Course Study Notes: hsctutoringnotes@outlook.com The Home Fronts in Britain and Germany Total War and its Economic and Social Impact on Civilians • • • • • WW1 was different where the communities left behind became participants in the home front which was vital to the outcome of the conflict Total war was where all activities of civilians and industry were directed to the war effort, and where the conflict isn’t limited to the battlefield Home fronts were seen as reservoirs of men, and the link developed from the battlefield to the home front was unprecendented States were organized more than ever before, calling on all resources; as well as a high level of patriotism and nationalism Both Britain and Germany depended highly on a supply of war materials, leading to the allied naval blockade and the german unrestricted submarine warfare Germany • • • • At the outbreak of......

Words: 20870 - Pages: 84

Salvation - Saison 2 | Miscellaneous Center | Watch movie