Premium Essay

Indian and the Dam

In: Social Issues

Submitted By ltolomeo
Words 2048
Pages 9
The Indians and the Dam

The Indians and the Dam
I.Title Page: The Indians and the Dam
II. Introduction: Indian burial ground being flooded by dam when at high level
III. Body. A. Is this dispute cultural, racial, or ethnic? 1. Why it is not racial 2. Why it is not ethnic dispute 3. Why it is cultural (DeVry, 2014)
This section will attempt to label the dispute. Define from a social stand point what is at the heart of this struggle. Asking is it ethnic, racial or cultural? Why is it important to solve?
B. The political and economic affect 1. Loss of recreational use 2. Loss of hydroelectricity 3. Possible damages from Flooding 4. Possible political reactions from Indian communities (CNN, 2008) 5. Possible political reaction from the dependent communities
This section will look at the possible effect on both the Indian and local communities that use the dam. What the actual ramifications of keeping the dam at low water levels would mean. Also explore the political drama that it could create of nothing is done. C. Possible Solutions 1. Monetary settlement (NY Times, 2009) 2. Relocation of site 3. Building Protective Structure 4. Leaving alone, status quo
This section will look at possible solutions. The feasibility of each solution given. Also who would be responsible for the cost? IV. Conclusion: Address the need for mutual respect among different cultures and the importance of compromise during disputes. (CNN, 2013)

The Indians and the Dam
Struggles with the American Indian are well documented in history. From the time European colonist started to settled in the Americas, to the fierce battles over land in 1800’s and 1900’s, to modern day legal conflicts it seems the United States in one way or another finds itself in some type of clash with its original citizens.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Dam Case

...BUILDING A DAM Central Problem: Whether to construct the proposed dam that would bring most benefit to the community and to lose a certain species of small fish only found in that river. Minor problem: A reasonable decision to not build the dam should the fish be edible and with commercial use. Alternative Courses of Action: 1. To continue in the construction the proposed dam so that the community will be benefited in terms of having hydroelectric power and creating recreational activities such as boating, swimming and water-skiing, however the river will lose that certain species of small fish. Applying the principle of utilitarianism which to sacrifice something for a greater good. 2. To transfer the small fish with the help of a government sector like the DENR, or government agency concerning aquatic life forms/ resources to a fish sanctuary or a new habitat before building the dam/ project so that this certain species of small fish will not become extinct. 3. To reject the proposed construction of the dam and preserve the existence of the small fish. Recommendation/Ethical Solution: The group recommends the second alternative course of action. The members of the group believe that although there will be additional costs in the transfer of the small fish; still we took into consideration of the possible extinction of the species. And in the very first place the ones responsible may it be the government or a private group for the proposal of the dam should......

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Coulee Dam

...Robert Schiller Grand Coulee Dam The Grand Coulee Dam was hailed as the "Eighth Wonder of the World" in 1941 when it was finished being built. It blocks the Columbia River with 12 million cubic yards of concrete, and spreads over a mile wide with the height of a 46-story building all holding back a 150-mile long reservoir called Lake Roosevelt. The dam produces more kilowatts than any other dam in the United States. The Grand Coulee was only part of the Columbia Basin Project that included four additional dams, three reservoir lakes, and approximately 2,300 miles of irrigation canals all making their way through a half a million acres of desert. It has been deemed as the largest public works project that has had the greatest impact on the economic development of the Pacific Northwest. But, the social and environmental costs were severe that the Grand Coulee Dam more than likely could not be built today. The Bonneville Power Administration (BPA) hired folksinger Woody Guthrie in May 1941, to promote the federal dams on the Columbia River. The issue was who should build the dams: private power companies or the federal government. The power companies had a stable of influential lobbyists. The government had Guthrie, whose generation felt the undammed river was a resource going to waste. Guthrie earned $266.66 and spent the month traveling around the Columbia Basin writing 26 songs in 30 days. The most famous of these is "Roll on Columbia, Roll On," sung to the tune of......

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Dams Removal

...property (the tsunami in 2004[iii]…). Throughout the history of the world, dams and reservoirs have been used successfully in collecting, storing and managing water needed to sustain civilization, with water supply as primary benefit of dams but also irrigation for agriculture (food supply), flood control, hydropower, inland navigation, recreation… Although dams provide significant benefits to societies, their impacts are diverse and include resettlement and relocation, socioeconomic impacts, environmental ecological concerns, sedimentation issues… The dams in the Pacific Northwest are not an exception. Indeed, these dams constitute an obstacle to the movement of species and sediment (sand, mud ...). For animal species, particularly migratory species (salmon…), these dams block access to breeding and cause the death of many individuals, even when there are fish ladders[iv]. Moreover dams trap sediments that accumulate and concentrate the pollutants in the water retention basin (video about the polluted water). The lack of supply of new sediment downstream of the dam could cause erosion problems that affect aquatic environments, collapsing banks or nibble beaches. The Elwha River, located in the Northwest of the US used to be full of salmons before the construction of the dams and the salmons represent a resource non negligible that must be protected for the growing world population. Although these dams produce hydropower, they should be removed because they aren’t......

Words: 539 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Dam

...Mary Williams February 14, 2013 International Law II – Welling Hall Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Dam On September 16, 1977, we, the People’s Republic of Hungary signed onto the Budapest Treaty with, then, the Czechoslovak Socialist Republic to initiate a large barrage project on an international watercourse, the Danube River. It was mutually understood that this project would improve shipping access and river navigability, reduce flooding, and produce much needed clean hydropower for both nation states. This project was an exciting endeavor to improve economic development in both our countries through the utilization of our shared watercourse. However, soon after work began on the project in 1978, new evidence emerged that there would be massive environmental consequences to the Danube because of the construction and operation of the System of Locks. The general public of Hungary held strong opposition to the continuation of the project as a direct response to environmental protection concerns. After several years of negotiations, we, the People’s Republic of Hungary, suspended our work on the project in 1989, eventually terminating the treaty in 1992, in the recognition that the environmental devastation would be too adverse to justify the potential economic development to be gained from the project. Slovakia, despite their knowledge of the potential and probable environmental devastation, unilaterally constructed and put into operation a modified system called “Variant C.” ...

Words: 1123 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Dam Group

...We as a researcher choose 'interview' as a data instrument gathering.We find 10 barangay's around La Mesa Dam including Brgy. Payatas district 2,Brgy Greater Lagro,Brgy. Pasong Tamo, Brgy. Sta Lucia,Brgy. North Fairview, Brgy. Gulod,Brgy. Fairview,Brgy. Katuparan,Brgy. Batasan Hills,and Brgy. Culiai. The following names are the barangay officials and their terms for each brgy. Mr.Obet Malasaga,the administrator of the Brgy. Fairview has been working for 7 yrs in the said barangay. Ms. Jamie Garcia,the administrator of the Brgy. Culiai has been working for 15 yrs in the said barangay.Mr. Edgar Macario works as a member of the brgy. For 3 yrs in Brgy.Batasan Hills. Mr.Jose Gaviola serves for 11 yrs in Brgy.Commonwealth. Mr.Emmanuel "Banso" Pilar serves as a Brgy. Captain in Brgy.Pasong Tamo for 5 yrs and 4 mos.Mr.Antonio del Rosario serves for almost 4 yrs in Brgy.Gulod as a member of the barangay.Executive officer: P/S Supt.Miguel G. Mariano Sr. works at Brgy.Greater Lagro as a BPSO from october 2012 up to the present.Mr.Ronaldo G. Anasco serves as a BPSO in Brgy.Sta Lucia for 4 yrs.Mr.Bonifacio Red Sr.works as a desk officer at Brgy.Payatas district 2 and Mr.Ranny Adoro also works as a desk officer/team leader in Brgy.North Fairview Hall since 2001 up to the present.The Purpose of the interview is to show what kind of life nd how people interact if there is a calamity and how prepare they are in times of a suden disaster. The main issues discussed during the......

Words: 1482 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Indian

...The British Colonization in Indian Introduction East India Company, also known as The Honorable East India Company, British East India Company, was a joint-stock company established by the British. On Dec. 31th, 1600, the company was chartered by the Queen Elizabeth as the Governor and Company of Merchants of London trading into the East Indies (Chaudhuri, 2006). The charter in fact gave East India Company a monopoly right for twelve years. During its rule in India, the company not only owned economic monopoly but also assisted the British to realize military expansion. There will first be a discussion about how East India Company assisted British to realize its military expansion in India. Following that, there will be a discussion on how East India Company works as an economic tool of colonial expansion for Britain. Finally, there will be a discussion on how East India Company finally led to the backwardness of the country as well as disaster of the local people. Military expansion The British colonization in India is actually a military expansion, which not only struck some other foreign colonial powers but also led to the elimination of local rulers (Nicholas, 1992). As a result, the colonization in fact had made a preparation for the later centralization of authority. The French army was defeated in the Seven Years’ War in India. As a result, the French no longer dear to expand its power in India, which also prevented the development of its industrial revolution....

Words: 1670 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Indians

...1 INDIANS Donna Rose History204 Tami Depasse July 14, 2014 2 “Go West Young Man” (Greeley, H. 1865) and West is where we went. Which marked the beginning of the end of the American Indians way of life. A life that was once peaceful and prosperous for the Sioux Indians was about to change drastically. Throughout history, the Sioux Indians, had to fight physical and emotional battles, in trying to retain their land and dignity. Following a time line, the American Indians were treated unjustly, as I will show starting with the Bozeman Trail and continuing on with The Great Sioux Reservation, Custer’s expedition, Battle of the Little Big Horn, Ghost Dancers, Wounded Knee, Citizenship Act of 1924, The Indian Reorganization Act, and The American Movement(AIM). The terrains were rough, being brutal and forcibly tough, especially for the new settlers who came west, when there was talk of gold. John Jacobs and his partner John...

Words: 3069 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

The Three Gorges Dam

...The Three Gorges Dam This Case-in-Point focuses on Hydropower energy produced by daming the Yangze River.The author talks about how it would benefit the people who live in the river basin because in they have faced droughts and floods so the reservior will help the agriculture productivity without having to worry about flooding issues that have happened in the past. The author states that the dam's can produce over 18 GW of electrical power which is equivalent to 18 nuclear power plants or large coal power plants which can help improve the problems that china has been facing with air pollution and its reliance on imported energy.The reservior according to the author can open another option for transporation as well. Although this seems like an amazing idea and has a lot of positive attributs. There are a significant amount of negative effects that can result from the reservoir. The author explains the different negative effects that it can have such as danger to some of the wildlife and the increased risk of waterborne diseases spreading throughout the community. This author does a great job at explaining the different aspects including positive and negative effects that can come from the resevior. I believe that the reservior could be a very good thing for this area. Although it may seem as if the negative effects outway the positive effects, If the community makes sure that they put a HIGH emphasis on making sure that the reservior is maintained well and that the......

Words: 275 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Giao Dich Dam Bao

...DỊCH BẢO ĐẢM CHÍNH PHỦ Căn cứ Luật Tổ chức Chính phủ ngày 25 tháng 12 năm 2001; Căn cứ Bộ luật Dân sự ngày 14 tháng 6 năm 2005; Căn cứ Nghị quyết số 45/2005/QH11 ngày 14 tháng 6 năm 2005 của Quốc hội về việc thi hành Bộ luật Dân sự; Xét đề nghị của Bộ trưởng Bộ Tư pháp, NGHỊ ĐỊNH : Chương 1: NHỮNG QUY ĐỊNH CHUNG Điều 1. Phạm vi điều chỉnh Nghị định này quy định chi tiết thi hành một số điều của Bộ luật Dân sự về việc xác lập, thực hiện giao dịch bảo đảm để bảo đảm thực hiện nghĩa vụ dân sự và xử lý tài sản bảo đảm. Điều 2. Áp dụng pháp luật Việc xác lập, thực hiện giao dịch bảo đảm và xử lý tài sản bảo đảm được thực hiện theo quy định của Bộ luật Dân sự, Nghị định này và các văn bản quy phạm pháp luật có liên quan. Điều 3. Giải thích từ ngữ Trong Nghị định này, các từ ngữ dưới đây được hiểu như sau: 1. Bên bảo đảm là bên có nghĩa vụ hoặc người thứ ba cam kết bảo đảm thực hiện nghĩa vụ dân sự, bao gồm bên cầm cố, bên thế chấp, bên đặt cọc, bên ký cược, bên ký quỹ, bên bảo lãnh và tổ chức chính trị - xã hội tại cơ sở trong trường hợp tín chấp. 2. Bên nhận bảo đảm là bên có quyền trong quan hệ dân sự mà việc thực hiện quyền đó được bảo đảm bằng một hoặc nhiều giao dịch bảo đảm, bao gồm bên nhận cầm cố, bên nhận thế chấp, bên nhận đặt cọc, bên nhận ký cược, bên nhận bảo lãnh, tổ chức tín dụng trong trường hợp tín chấp và bên có quyền được ngân hàng thanh toán, bồi thường thiệt hại trong trường hợp ký quỹ. 3. Bên nhận bảo đảm ngay tình là bên nhận bảo đảm trong......

Words: 10573 - Pages: 43

Free Essay

Three Gorges Dam

...paper was prepared for BIO 330: Principles of Ecology, Module 1 Homework Assignment taught by Shannon Unger. PART 1: ECOLOGICAL CONTROVERSY After reading through the website dedicated to the Three Gorges Dam, reading through a few additional websites and articles, and watching a few videos, I have made a personal determination that I am not on one side of the debate or the other. Unfortunately for me, I can see both sides of the debate and can understand why the dam is good, and why it was thought to be a negative and its current impacts on the nation. So rather than argue one side or the other, I am going to lay out both the positives and the negatives of the dam, and maybe and some point down the road, I will have a better take on the overall positive or negative impact the Three Gorges Dam has really done. So let us start off with the positive aspects of what the dam brought to the Yangtze River Valley. The work on the dam began in 1993 and final construction was completed in 2009. The three main purposes of the dam are hydroelectric power production, flood control, and navigation improvement for the shipping lanes. The power production of the Three Gorges Dam sits as the world largest power station at 22,500 MW (Mega Watts). With 32 water driven turbines inside the dam, the 98.8 TWh (Terawatthours) was enough to provide energy for 10% of Chinas population at a staggering 136 million people. This energy is equivalent to 18 nuclear power plants and at a fraction......

Words: 1567 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Indian

...Indian Distributors Ltd. Prof. Ramesh Behl Indian Distributors Ltd. was originally started as a small trader who used to import goods from third world countries and sell these in India. Slowly, it expanded its business to an ‘Importing House’. It was established about fifty years back and, over the years, has built up a substantial nation-wide selling and distribution organization within India. Its headquarters is in Mumbai, but it has warehouses and Regional Sales Offices in Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai, Jaipur, Lucknow and Amritsar. Over and above the Regional Sales Officers, it also has Regional Sales Centres in all the major towns of all States of India. Although the business started purely as an importing business, it has created a strong selling and distribution network on the basis of imported product range. The existence of a strong distribution and selling network enabled them to take on distributorships of a wide range of Indian manufacturers. Today, they sell about 50% of indigenous manufactured products, while 50% products continue to be imported from other countries. The imported items of course involve license formalities, and a separate license section has been established (adjacent to the Delhi Regional Sales Office) to deal with these matters. License Section job is also to liaison with customs department and other agencies. Indian Distributors Ltd. markets several range of machines and other household consumable products. The machines range......

Words: 2012 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Hoover Dam

...2: Hoover Dam The Hoover Dam, once known as the Boulder Dam, is a concrete arch-gravity dam in the Black Canyon of the Colorado River, on the border between Arizona and Nevada. It was constructed between 1931 and 1936 during the Great Depression and it was dedicated on September 30, 1935, by President Franklin D. Roosevelt. Its construction was the result involving thousands of workers and unfortunately cost over one hundred lives. The dam was controversially named after President Herbert Hoover. The center of Boulder City, Elm Street, had been surrounded by the Grace Community Church. Reverend Thomas Stevenson was sure of delivering forgiveness to the town over the corruption of the project of the reservation. Most likely it would gather many citizens of Nevada, but mostly to prove if Tom Stevenson was part of it, then it had to be done. Since about 1900, the Black Canyon and nearby Boulder Canyon had been investigated for their potential support a dam that would control floods, provide irrigation water and produce hydroelectric power. In 1928, Congress authorized the project. The winning bid to build the dam was submitted by a consortium called Six Companies, Inc., which began construction on the dam in early 1931. Such a large concrete structure had never been built before, and some of the techniques were unproven. The fervid summer weather and the lack of facilitates near the site also presented difficulties. Nevertheless, Six Companies turned over the dam to the......

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Guri Dam

...The Guri Dam Case Study Analysis The Guri Dam, located on the Caroni River in Venezuela, was an idea born from the country’s necessity for economic development and reduce its dependency on its own oil rich reserves. The project was meant to aim Venezuela’s electric power generation from hydrocarbon to hydroelectric and reduce the country’s reliance on carbon based electricity, thus allowing the sale and exportation of more petroleum products. With the realization that Venezuela’s oil reserves were going to be a fundamental basis in the nation’s economic growth and stability, the Venezuelan government hired a consulting firm to develop the plan. From the start, the project had a well-defined scope, which potentially led to the project’s major success. Financed by the Venezuelan government and the World Bank, the 23 year project was completed on time and well within budget. Country leaders did an exceptional job during the planning and inception phase. Coporacion Venezolana de Guayana (CVG) was established in 1960 to study and develop the hydroelectric potential of the Caroni river. CVG outsourced the economic and technical studies of the river and the feasibility of building the Hydroelectric Central Guri (Guri Dam) to a North American Company. Eldeca, a company created in 1963 was given charge of the project and all subsequent operations of the dam. Eldeca’s management style and forethought proved to be a huge success during the course of the project. Eldeca......

Words: 834 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Indian

...kumar Ph.d scholar in public administration, kurukshetra university Narender joon LL.M, Kurukshetra university kurukshetra INTRODUCTION: The most operational irritants to Centre State Relations springs in administrative sphere & they have led to most slanderous accusation against executive functionaries and decision makers. It is an area in which seemingly detailed provisions of the Constitution have not helped much. In the modern administrative age, administration plays a very significant role by way of enforcing the law of promoting socio-economic welfare of the people. The pattern of administrative relationship between the Centre and the State, therefore, assumes a great significance in developing country like India. The Indian Constitution contains more elaborate provisions regarding the administrative relation between the Centre and the States than are to be found in any of the three federation of the U.S.A., Canada and Australia. The Constitution lays down a flexible and permissive and not a rigid scheme of allocation of administrative responsibilities between the Centre and State. The scheme is so designed as to permit all kind of co-operative administrative arrangement between the two levels of Government. It is notable, however, that though legislative and judicial power is defined by the Constitution, this is not the case with the executive in our Constitution. Some Constitutional experts like Wade & Philips, try to define executive functions......

Words: 4462 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Indians

...The Mohawk Indians are a group of Native Americans indigenous to what is now New York, the Mohawks Is one of many of the remaining native tribes in the United States. The Mohawks are a farming culture known for their great battle skills and the organization of their political groups. The tribe gained their name which means “man eaters” from tribal enemies and Europeans . The tribe is a part of the original Iroquois Indian league were they shared the same culture and language. The Mohawks are notable for their longhouse dwellings, excellent craftsmanship, tribal music and storytelling (which is still a vital part of tribal life today). The Mohawk Indians are a group of Native Americans indigenous to what is now New York, the Mohawks Is one of many of the remaining native tribes in the United States. The Mohawks are a farming culture known for their great battle skills and the organization of their political groups. The tribe gained their name which means “man eaters” from tribal enemies. The tribe is a part of the original Iroquois Indian league were they shared the same culture and language. The Mohawks are notable for their longhouse dwellings, excellent craftsmanship, tribal music and storytelling (which is still a vital part of tribal life today). Religion The Mohawk people had their own religion were they worshiped the creator and the belief that all living things had a spirit which they honored and protected , the Mohawk people had......

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

The Big Take | PILOT G2 Ersatzmine * 5 Stück * Mine Gelschreiber Gelmine refill G-2 07 BLS-G2-7 | 16GB 8GB 4GB USB 2.0 Swivel Flash Memory Stick Pen Drive Storage Thumb U Disk FT