Guidelines in Critiquing Researches

In: English and Literature

Submitted By JLPaglinawan
Words 924
Pages 4
Guidelines for Critiquing a Qualitative Research Study | Elements influencing the believability of the research | Elements | Questions | Writing Style | Is the article well written – concise, grammatically correct, avoid use of jargons? Is it well laid out and organized? | Title | Is the title clear, accurate and unambiguous | Abstract | Does the abstract offer a clear overview of the study including the research problem, sample, methodology, finding, and recommendations? | Elements influencing the robustness of the research | Elements | Questions | Purpose/research problem | Is the purpose of the study/research problem clearly identified? | Logical consistency | Does the research report follow the steps of the research process in a logical manner? Do these steps naturally flow and are the links clear? | Literature Review | Is the review logically organized? Does it offer balanced critical analysis of the literature? Is the majority of the literature of recent origin? Is it mainly from primary sources and of an empirical nature | Theoretical framework | Has the conceptual or theoretical framework been identified? Is the framework adequately described? Is the framework appropriate? | Method and philosophical underpinnings | Has the philosophical approach been identified? Why was this approach/ method chosen? | Research setting | Was the setting properly and completely described? Were the circumstances under which the data was collected described? | Sample | Is the sampling method and sample size described? Is the sampling method appropriate? Were the participants properly and completely described? Were the participants suitable for informing the research purpose as described? | Ethical considerations | Were the participants fully informed about the nature of the research? Was the autonomy/confidentiality of the participants guaranteed?…...

Similar Documents

Guidelines

...Research Paper Guidelines Use the following guidelines for your English 272 paper: 1. Topic: Must be a work or author from your textbook’s table of contents, but this work/author must not be on the syllabus nor discussed in the video lectures. The topic must also be approved by your instructor, and you must focus your paper’s content on some aspect of the writer’s work, not his/her life. You must also NOT provide a book report merely discussing the plot of a work. 2. Length of Paper: 4 pages minimum; 7 pages maximum 3. Formatting Standard: MLA (Modern Language Association) 4. Sources: 5 minimum – all academic sources (no .com sites) 5. Line spacing: Double 6. Margins: 1” (top, bottom, left, and right) 7. Font: Times New Roman 12 8. Header: Your last name and page number (in the top right corner of each page) 9. Title Page: None 10. First Page Additional Information: Type beginning on line 1 and double space: Name – Turnitin.com ID number Mrs. Long ENG272 Online Date 11. Parenthetical Citations: These are necessary for all quoted, paraphrased, and summarized material. Place the parenthetical citation after source’s material. Place the period after the parenthetical citation. 12. Works Cited page: Sources in alphabetical order, double spaced, with hanging indent. 13. Grading: 1/3 grammar 1/3 content (length, number of sources, depth of research, relevance to course, level of work) 1/3 style (MLA) MLA Hints (for Works Cited......

Words: 379 - Pages: 2

Theory Critiquing

...factors mentioned by the said theory and consequently the basis for providing nursing care. This determines the activities of living patients need most assistance.                                                                                                                       By: Jessa Lorraine D. Andalan Based on my experience as an Operating Theatre Nurse, the model helps me assess clients and give substantial report to the anesthesiologist in order for him to know if the client is fit to surgery or not before going inside the Operating Theatre. It also helps us as a surgical team to give safe and therapeutic environment to the client. Roper, Logan, Tierney's Theory provides quality health assessment tool and serves as a nursing guidelines in intervening the client. As a result, it provides quality nursing care.                                                                                                                                By: Gina Bacud       In an ICU set-up all patients are dependent to the nurses. Thus, it is our responsibility to help fulfill their needs and aid them in becoming more independent. In applying the 5 factors in influencing activities of daily living in the Roper, Logan, Tierney model of nursing, we consider a holistic approach towards the patient. This includes biological, pyschological, sociocultural, environmental and politico-economic. My job as an ICU nurse is not only to attend to the physical needs of my patient, I also......

Words: 4036 - Pages: 17

Guidelines

...General Format MLA style specifies guidelines for formatting manuscripts and using the English language in writing. MLA style also provides writers with a system for referencing their sources through parenthetical citation in their essays and Works Cited pages. Writers who properly use MLA also build their credibility by demonstrating accountability to their source material. Most importantly, the use of MLA style can protect writers from accusations of plagiarism, which is the purposeful or accidental uncredited use of source material by other writers. If you are asked to use MLA format, be sure to consult the MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers (7th edition). Publishing scholars and graduate students should also consult the MLA Style Manual and Guide to Scholarly Publishing (3rd edition). The MLA Handbook is available in most writing centers and reference libraries; it is also widely available in bookstores, libraries, and at the MLA web site. See the Additional Resources section of this handout for a list of helpful books and sites about using MLA style. Paper Format The preparation of papers and manuscripts in MLA style is covered in chapter four of the MLA Handbook, and chapter four of the MLA Style Manual. Below are some basic guidelines for formatting a paper in MLA style. General Guidelines • Type your paper on a computer and print it out on standard, white 8.5 x 11-inch paper. • Double-space the text of your paper, and use a legible font (e.g.......

Words: 617 - Pages: 3

Guidelines

...GUIDELINES FOR PREPARATION OF PROJECT REPORT 1. ARRANGEMENT OF CONTENTS: The sequence in which the project report material should be arranged and bound should be as follows: 1. Title Page 2. Declaration / Supervisor Certificate 3. Acknowledgement 4. Table of Contents 5. List of Tables 6. List of Figures 7. List of Symbols, Abbreviations and Nomenclature 8. Abstract 9. Chapters 10. Appendices 11. References The table and figures shall be introduced in the appropriate places. 2. PAGE DIMENSION AND BINDING SPECIFICATIONS: The dimension of the project report should be in A4 size. The project report should be bound using flexible cover of the thick white art paper. The cover should be printed in black letters and the text for printing should be identical. 3. PREPARATION FORMAT: 3.1 Cover Page & Title Page – A specimen copy of the Cover page & Title page of the project report are given in Appendix 1. 3.2 Declaration / Supervisor Certificate – A specimen copy of the Cover page & Title page of the project report are given in Appendix 2. 3.3 Acknowledgement: 3.4 Abstract – Abstract should be one page synopsis of the project report typed double line spacing, Font Style Times New Roman and Font Size 12. 3.5 Table of Contents – The table of contents should list all material......

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

Critiquing Child Advocacy Plans.

...Critiquing Child Advocacy Plans Child, Family, Community and Culture-ECH-325 July 3. 2013 Critiquing Child Advocacy Plans While talking to the local school district administrator of the elementary school and the director of the pre-k in the Arizona school system, I was informed that anyone that has reason to believe that a child is being harmed in any way, such as physically, mentally or affected by neglect or abuse must report these cases to the local law enforcement agency and to the Department of Protective Services. It is the responsibility of ever member of the school staff to report any suspected abuse to their superiors at the school district office. It doesn’t matter how small the problem may be to the staff member it is part of their responsibility to provide their students with a safe environment and protection. If the staff doesn’t report any suspected abuse they can be sent to jail or fined. If a student comes to any staff member and reports sexual abuse that has taken place, it is not considered hearsay, and it is considered admissible in court. This will only hold up in court if I am the first adult the child has told this story to. If a report is made in good faith, any member of the staff will have legal protection and their identity will be kept confidential. This means that I have taken actions without intending to hurt anyone. The district administrator and director has informed me that they have had experienced where they had to call CPS. They...

Words: 931 - Pages: 4

Guidelines

...-FORMAT- Guidelines for Writing an Action Research Project The basic steps 1. Review your current practice 2. Identify an aspect that you want investigate 3. Collect and Organize data 4. Interpret data and imagine a solution or a way forward 5. Try it out and take stock of what happened 6. Monitor what you do 7. Review and evaluate the modified action The Contents: The Manuscript will include the following items: (Cover Page Title information, name, date) Table of contents (list the items with appropriate page numbers) Introduction: Objectives -Clearly describe the purpose of the study and its significance - Introduce factors that initially prompted you to ask this question. How did the idea Originate? -Describe how answering the question might improve your practice. Related Literature Review: -Identify the aspects of your research question. -Introduce the main theories that allow you to discuss your project. -Define the basic terminology and concepts related to discuss your project. -Summary of the state of the art presents the Literature for each part of the question Methodology and work plan: -detail and justify the method and the work plan you put forward. The Study: The Context (Provide a brief description of your site) -Clearly describe the chosen setting (Classroom, school etc.) Include all pertinent information available. -Situate the question in......

Words: 553 - Pages: 3

Guideline

...Term paper guidelines * Length of paper * Structure * Title page * Table of contents * Inappropriate table of contents * Appropriate table of contents * Table of contents in brief * Introduction * Literature review * Methodology * Results * Discussion * Conclusion * Bibliography * Appendix * Citation guidelines * Quotations * Referencing * Second-hand quoting/ referencing * Style/ accuracy * Presentation/ formating * Inclusion of examples * Use of footnotes/ endnotes * Comments on plagerism * Major pitfalls of writing term papers * Assessment sheet * Links to term paper guidelines * Further readings * References to possible ideas for projects in linguistics * The University of Maryland Undergraduate Essay Prize in Linguistics   Length of paper Proseminar: The paper should be type-written (1.5 spaced) and between 10 and 15 pages in length. Hauptseminar: Papers should be type-written (1.5 spaced) and between 20 to 25 pages long. Structure Term papers should be composed of the following sections: Title page Table of contents Introduction Literature review Methodology Results Discussion Conclusion Bibliography Appendix Generally, the introduction and theoretical part should account for a third of the paper and...

Words: 5706 - Pages: 23

Critiquing

...possibly distort some aspects of the original research (Polit and Hungler 1997; Burns and Grove 1993). The purpose of the literature review is to discuss what is known, identify gaps in knowledge, establish the significance of the study and situate the study within the current body of knowledge (Polit and Hungler 1997). This is supported by Burns and Grove (2001), who consider the primary purpose of reviewing the literature is to gain a broad background or understanding of the available information related to the problem. The researcher should also critically appraise and use the literature to inform their thinking and methodology (Polit and Hungler 1997). The search should consider how the major variables were explored previously by critiquing the strengths and limitations of the methods used eg design, sample and instrument (Burns and Grove 2001). The literature Review is Therefore carried Out after The data Have been collected. The aim of this approach is to explore concepts embedded in the data, thereby allowing theory to be generated from the data rather than vice versa (Robinson,2002) Title. The title does not validate or invalidate the research (Parahoo and Reid 1988). Author Ryan Wenger (1992) notes the authors brief biographies may be important sources of information about academic degrees, certification, position and place of employment, from which clinical and research expertise can sometimes be discerned. Date Research papers......

Words: 1099 - Pages: 5

Guideline

...capital flows to capital market reforms including India. And two, to understand the investment allowing private mutual funds to operate, behaviour of foreign portfolio investors through allowing investment in Indian firms an analysis of the portfolios of five US-based by foreign investors and allowing India specific funds. Such an exercise, it is increased access to world capital hoped, would explain the relationship between markets for Indians (emphasis added).3 foreign institutional investments and trading pattern in the Indian stock market better than Attracting foreign capital appears to be the aggregate level analysis. main reason for opening up of the stock markets for FIIs [Lalitha, 1992]. The Government of India issued the relevant Guidelines for FII investment FPI and India on September 14, 1992. Only a few days prior to While foreign portfolio investments are not this, a statement attributed to IFC suggested that new to the Indian corporate sector, the India would have to wait for some years importance of portfolio investments received before the expected large foreign investment [Financial Express, 1992]. special impetus towards the end of 1992 when materialises Regarding the entry of FIIs the then Finance the F oreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) such as Pension Funds, Mutual Funds, Investment Minister said at a meeting organised by the Institute of International Affairs Trusts, Asset Management Companies, Royal (London) that the decision to open up the stock......

Words: 14542 - Pages: 59

Guidelines

...Plan Name Institution Professor Course Date Guidelines for Confidentiality During the systemic referral process, disseminating research findings without disclosing personal identifying information is vital in order to enhance information security. Secondly, there is need of storing research records securely and limiting access to the unauthorized personnel that include removing, disguising, and coding personal identifying information (Reamer, 2000). Thirdly, since some data is very sensitive in relation to privacy, obtaining written information, need consent from various people who live in my town with special reference to disseminating findings that include video images and recordings that might reveal personal information during the referral process. In order to enhance confidentiality during this community resource co-ordination, Paper records containing personal information, should be secured in folders during the referral process, kept under the constant control and co-ordination. Lastly, during the dissemination of information during the referral process from one agency to another, it will be absolutely unethical and unprofessional if cell phone conversations are dominant. Individuals using higher technological devices because, cell phone conversations can be easily overheard or rather intercept this (Reamer, 2000). Guidelines for making, tracking, and assessing the success of referrals to each agency Making When I will be defining and making a referral, I...

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Guidelines for Critiquing a Quantitative Article

...Guidelines for Critiquing a Quantitative Article Write a critique on sections listed below. For each section, write a brief summary followed by a critique based on the bulleted points under each section. Introduction • Articulation or clear explanation of the research problem or issue • Identification of specific research question, and or hypothesis. Reflect on the purpose of the study. Exploratory or descriptive studies need not have an hypothesis. If research question is not identified, say so and write what you think the research question is. • What rationale for the study is offered? Does it clearly state the relevance of the study to social work practice, policy, or social work education? Review of the Literature • How exhaustive is it? Does it cover all aspects of the research problem? Does it cover information pertaining to all concepts and variables of importance? Are major studies in the field reviewed? • How current is the literature review to the date of publication? • Are the gaps in literature discussed? Methodology • Are the main aspects like research design, data source (e.g., participants) and their selection, Data collection instruments, data collection procedures, and data analysis included? Is each aspect clearly described? • Are ethical issues addressed? State if you have any question about ethical issues pertaining to the study. Results • Is sample adequately described? • Are findings clearly......

Words: 305 - Pages: 2

Guidelines

...GUIDELINES FOR PREPARING PROJECTED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Before entering into the nitty-gritty of the precautions to be taken by the professionals, first of all, I would like to throw some lights on the definitions of the basics of the Projected Financial Statements: WHAT IS FINANCIAL FORECASTS AND PROJECTIONS? Financial forecasts and projections are two types of prospective financial statements that attempt to reflect a company’s expected financial position and expected results of operations. FINANCIAL FORECAST A financial forecast reflects, to the best of the company’s knowledge, the expected financial results of a future period. It is based on expected conditions and expected courses of action. It is to be noted that in almost all situations, the party responsible for the prospective financial statements is the management of the company. FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS A financial projection is different than a forecast in that it is based on hypothetical assumptions. A projection reflects the financial position and results of operations based on a “What if” type of scenario. It is to be noted that only a financial forecast is appropriate for general use. Now, I would like to touch upon those areas, which needs to be taken care of and needs some fine-tuning before accepting any assignment of preparing/compiling of projected financial statements. PRECAUTIONS TO BE TAKEN BY THE PROFESSIONALS BEFORE COMPILING PROJECTED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 1. Make sure that...

Words: 690 - Pages: 3

Guidelines

...Thesis Format Guidelines UGC approved: April 28, 2006 These guidelines are designed to provide the formatting requirements for all theses and project reports submitted to Mewar University. It contains the basic structure, layout, form, and style are required for the purpose, however, Candidates/ Departments may use additional requirements, if needed, provide that does not conflict with the guidelines contained in this document. 1. Thesis and Project Report Arrangement Assemble the thesis/project report in this order: 1. Cover page: includes the title, author, degree (“Thesis/Project submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Ph.D. of … in …”), and date. 2. Cover page color: Pink 3. Thesis/Project Approval Form. 4. Plagiarism policy compliance statement. 5. Copyright page that grants MU the right to use and reproduce fully or partially the work being presented. 6. Dedication page (optional). 7. Acknowledgments page (optional). 8. Abstract: a concise summary of the essential information of the work being presented, namely of the study’s scope, purpose and results. The reference-free single spaced abstract should not exceed two pages. 9. Table of Contents: includes all the subsections of each chapter and the list of appendices (if applicable) and page numbers. 10. List of Figures: includes figure number, caption, and the page number. 11. List of Tables: includes table number, caption, and the page number. 12.......

Words: 2654 - Pages: 11

Guidelines

...My Leadership SMART Goal: Guidelines Purpose The purpose of this assignment is to develop a SMART-formatted goal related to your professional leadership applicable to your current practice setting or future leadership aspirations. This goal is about YOUR leadership development, not those of the organization or the department where you work. Many organizations have developed the SMART-goal framework as they strive for performance improvement. Your goal may tie to one of the departmental or organizational SMART goals but the components of the goal are about YOUR leadership development The Institute of Medicine’s quality initiative has identified five core healthcare profession competencies. This assignment focuses on only two of those initiatives. Either Patient-Centered Care or Working in Interdisciplinary and/or Interprofessional Teams will serve as a framework for identification of YOUR leadership SMART goal. Course Outcomes Completion of this assignment enables the student to meet the following course outcomes. CO 1: Apply leadership concepts, skills, and decision making in the provision of high quality nursing care, healthcare team management, and the oversight and accountability for care delivery in a variety of settings. (PO #2) CO 4: Apply concepts of leadership and team coordination to promote the achievement of safe and quality outcomes of care for diverse populations. (PO #4) CO 5: Apply improvement methods, based on data from the outcomes of care......

Words: 1906 - Pages: 8

Guideline

...GUIDELINES ON FOODS, DRINKS AND GOODS UTILIZED BY MUSLIMS INTRODUCTION The majority of processors of food and goods utilized by Muslims do not fully comprehend the meaning of the labels 'HALAL'(Permisible), 'CERTIFIED HALAL', 'FOOD FOR MUSLIMS' and other similar labellings as provided for in the 'Trade Description Act(Usage of Statement'HALAL/Permissible') 1975' Thus, these guidelines are prepared to interpret and explain, to processors and the public, the halal and haram aspects as stipulated in Islamic laws.It covers foods, drinks, slaughtering and utensils used by muslims. These guidelines contain the following particulars: * Important definitions as provided for in the Trade Description Act ( Usage of Statement 'HALAL') 1975 * Sources of foods and drinks * Slaughtering * Presentation and Storage * Processing and cooking of food * Hygiene * Utilized Goods * The Label Halal(Permissible) * Conclusion 1.IMPORTANT DEFINITIONS AS PROVIDED FOR IN THE TRADE DESCRIPTION ACT [ USAGE OF STATEMENT HALAL (PERMISSIBLE) 1975] 1.1 ISLAMIC LAWS(SYARIAH LAWS) Islamic laws as stipulated in 'Fiqh Shafie' or laws as contained in any one of the fiqh of Maliki, Hambali or hanafi which are approved by the King and enforced in the Federal Territory, Malacca, Pulau Pinang , or approved by any other ruler to be enforced in any other state. The sources of these Islamic laws are the Al-Quran, hadis, Ijma' and Qiyas.Whichever food substance......

Words: 1342 - Pages: 6

Watch Movie | The Last Kingdom HDTV | University Challenge