Case Study 5.1 the First Audit

In: Business and Management

Submitted By brandysantiago8
Words 735
Pages 3
Brandy Santiago
MGT 410 Quality Improvement and Management
Dr. Kislal
Case Study 5.1 The First Audit

Quality Auditing is a management tool to systematically determine compliance to requirements. Poorly executed audits provide incomplete or inaccurate information upon which to base future decisions. The ISO 9000 and MBNQA standards and criteria are the two most frequently used audit standards in the United States.
Can John conduct an audit of his company’s quality management system given its present state? Discuss - A quality management system (QMS) is a collection of business processes focused on achieving quality policy and quality objectives to meet customer requirements. It is expressed as the organizational structure, policies, procedures, processes and resources needed to implement quality management.
Business success may simply be the extent to which your organization can produce a higher-quality product or service than your competitors are able to do at a competitive price.
When quality is the key to a company’s success, quality management systems allow organizations to keep up with and meet current quality levels, meet the consumer’s requirement for quality, retain employees through competitive compensation programs, and keep up with the latest technology. So no I don’t think John can conduct a proper audit. He’s missing too much important paper work.
What are some of the documentation requirements that John must address on order to develop his quality management system so that they comply with ISO9001? - Quality Manual - The quality manual defines how each requirement of the rather generic ISO 9001:2008 standard is applied at the company. In a sense, the ISO 9001 quality manual is a company specific version of the ISO 9001:2008 standard. The requirements for the content of the quality manual are defined in ISO 9001:2008 section 4.2.2.
Quality…...

Similar Documents

Case Study 5.1 Panera Bread

...Q1. How has Panera Bread established a unique position in the restaurant industry? How has this unique position contributed to the firm’s success? Do you think Panera Bread will reach its goal of becoming a leading national brand in the restaurant industry? Why or why not? Panera Bread has established a unique position in the restaurant industry by developing itself with various approaches. First of all, Panera Bread has observed the consumer always wanted good food quality and speed services. This has given the Panera Bread an opportunity to reposition itself by joining the concept of fast food and casual dining category. This category provided the consumer the alternative they wanted by capturing the advantages of the both categories. Besides, with the good timing which became the first mover to this new category also led itself to this favorable position. This new category has made Panera Bread’s position not only unique but also contributed to its success. Panera Bread did a lot of things to distinguish itself from its rivals such as adding specialty food, different menus, catering service, new time suggesting of specialty food and providing inviting neighborly atmosphere. According to the text, Panera Bread serves nearly six million customers a week systemwide and become one of the largest chains. This shows that the unique position has contributed to its success. In my opinion, I think Panera Bread will reach its goal because the company is relying on its unique......

Words: 1649 - Pages: 7

Audit Case

...Public Practice Audit Case Lectures and handouts by: Debbie Moy, BA. CGA 1 BC 2 – Assignment 1 •  Submission requirements for BC2 •  Assignment #1 •  Task 1 — Review client communication 7 marks •  Task 2 — Determine materiality and perform preliminary Analysis 9 •  Task 3 — Assess inherent risk. 6 •  Task 4 — Gain an understanding of the client's internal control environment and assess control risk. 4 24 marks 2 BC 2 – Assignment #2 •  Task 5 — Design and perform tests of controls and dual-purpose tests. 10 marks 3 1 BC 2-Assignment #3 •  Task 6 — Perform audit of cash and investments. 6 marks •  Task 7 — Perform audit of accounts receivable. 10 »  16 marks 4 BC 2 – Assignment #4 •  Task 8 — Perform audit of inventory. •  7 marks •  Task 9 — Perform audit of accounts payable. 6 13 marks 5 BC 2 – Assignment #5 •  Task 10 — Complete the audit. 35 marks Total: 100 marks 6 2 BC2- Introduction Public Practice Audit Case Contains: •  Part 1 Client Background •  Part 2 W/P Preparation. •  Part 3 Student tasks. •  Part 4 Working papers (ie. W/P) •  Part 5 Permanent File •  Part 6 Client documents •  Part 7 Blank W/Ps’ 7 BC2 Topics in Audio Tapes: •  Welcome to BC2- Public Practice Audit Case! •  Introduction •  Student tasks (#1 to #10) •  FAQ from students •  Disposition sheet and Deficiency List •  Handouts •  Lecturer’s ideas for success! 8 BC2 Introduction: •  How long does BC2 take to do? •  Computer requirements: ...

Words: 3007 - Pages: 13

Raft Accreditation Audit Case Study Task I

...Executive Summary of Accreditation Audit June 2012 I prepared and reviewed an accreditation audit for Nightingale Community Hospital to organize and ensure compliance with Joint Commission standards for our hospital. We are preparing for a site visit that should occur within the next 13 months. I have reviewed the current compliance status of our hospital and will explain our corrective action plan that will ensure compliance with the Joint Commission standards for the focus area of communication. An accreditation audit was performed by Carl Anderson, Director of Quality. We were only in 100% compliance in December throughout the year in one of the priority focus areas of the Joint Commission standard: Communication; Standard: UP.01.03.01; A time out is performed before the procedure. See chart below: This is the universal protocol for preventing wrong site, wrong procedure, and wrong Patient Surgeries. In evaluating this, I must review all standards that go hand in hand with the time-out standard; per Nightingale Community Hospital policy, Site Identification and Verification (Universal Protocol). I will address the elements of performance for all three: UP.01.01.01; Conduct a preprocedure verification process. UP.01.02.01; Mark the procedure site, and UP.01.03.01; A time-out is performed before the procedure. I will then address the items that are not addressed in Nightingale's policy in my corrective action plan and add any updates. (Commission, 2012)......

Words: 3313 - Pages: 14

Audit Case Study Fpl

...AUDIT & INGENIERIE DES ORGANISATIONS F R A N C E PA P E R L I N E SOMMAIRE I.  Contexte II.  Symptômes III.  Circuits de fonctionnement IV.  Diagnostic de l’entreprise FPL CONTEXTE •  France Paper Line (FPL) ⇒  Fabrication & commercialisation de papier/carton ⇒  Chiffre d’affaire 20XX = XX M ⇒  10 Maisons de vente •  Commande d’un client •  10 palettes de papier via internet •  Couleur et grammage unique •  Client insatisfait du service offert par FPL •  Récéption d’une lettre SYMPTOMES & CAUSES Symptôme Commande 1 Aucun accusé de réception Prise d'une nouvelle commande par le client "J'ai téléphoné … vers le service prise des commandes" Mauvaise relation commerciale X   Organisation défaillante   X S.I peu adapté aux nécéssités   X Potentiel humain faible     Symptôme Commande 2 Enregistrement de la nouvelle commande téléphonique Accusé de réception incomplet "Accusé de réception … c'est tout" Délais de livraisons non respectés "Une semaine après, toujours rien …" Signalement tardif du rejet de la commande Il doit lui même prendre contact Mauvaise relation commerciale   X   X X Organisation défaillante X   X X X S.I peu adapté aux nécéssités   X X X   Potentiel humain faible           SYMPTOMES & CAUSES Symptômes Commande 3 Contraint de choisir un produit de substitution Délais de livraisons non respectés Accusé de réception incomplet et tardif Personne n'est en charge du dossier Mauvaise relation commerciale     X X Organisation......

Words: 366 - Pages: 2

Case Study 5.1

...ORGANIZATIONAL ETHICS CASE STUDY 5.1 Q.1: Should Johann alter any details on his resume in order to land this job? Why or why not? If you answered yes, which information should he change? Yes he can add more details that can make his resume stronger. For example, he could say any details about his study in the University that related to the jobs' offer he applied. Also, he must to prepare a lot before the interview to convince the interviewer that he is the one that the Company need to hire for this position. Q.2: Are slight exaggerations more justified than outright lies on resumes? Yes, Slight exaggerations are more justified than outright lies on resumes. Q.3: Why is lying on resumes and in job interviews so widespread? Lying on resumes and in job interviews so widespread, because people are in dire need to have a job. Also, nowadays, there are lack of jobs, and most companies ask for at least two years experience. Q.4: What are the potential long-term consequences to an applicant for lying or withholding part of the truth on a resume? What are the consequences to the employer? When these happened, the potential consequences to an applicant is losing his reputation, his job and no one will hire him again. While, there are no consequences to the employer, unless the applicant did really bad job that lead the employer discovered his lie. The easiest thing he can do is fire the employee from his position. Q.5: What responsibility do organizations......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Case Study: the First Appraisal Interview

...performance growth. Ratings against a standard do not preclude comparisons. While employees may typically compare themselves to others, there is little to be gained by having the organization promote such comparisons. They are likely to create envy, vanity and dysfunctional competition. In this case, boss lets Sandy to compare with Charlie. It may create envy, vanity and dysfunctional competition. In a healthy organization, one employee’s success need not mean another’s failure. If all can succeed, much the better. Those who prefer an absolute standard tend to give lower scores to employees, as they fear new workers who receive high marks will not feel the need for further improvement. In contrast, raters who feel a worker has done superior work considering his time in the position, may rate him as such. An evaluation six months or a year later yielding a superior mark would require a corresponding improvement on the part of the worker. I prefer the latter approach, because it seems more positive. Supervisory evaluations often suffer from rating deficiencies: • One particularly good or poor trait may contaminate other performance areas considered in the evaluation. In this case, the boss rate Sandy as average. He figures out the poor trait during the evaluation period. Sandy drops the dishes. So he gives Sandy average. It is not helpful Sandy to improve in the further. • Once a worker is classified as a poor performer, it may take a long time for a supervisor to......

Words: 2014 - Pages: 9

Politeknik Audit Case Study 4

...creditors and thus revenues and earnings will be more important to stockholder decisions than creditor decisions b) Why are different materiality thresholds relevant for different audit engagements? Materiality is a relative rather than an absolute concept. The materiality threshold that will influence users of the financial statements will vary depending on the context in which the entity operates. For example, the magnitude of a misstatement that will influence financial statement users will vary depending on how the entity is performing relative to the industry. Misstatements of a smaller magnitude will be more influential for an entity just achieving the industry average compared to an entity significantly over- or under-achieving relative to the industry average. c) Why is the materiality base that results in the smallest threshold generally used for planning purposes? The dual entry nature of accounting results in misstatements affecting at least two accounts. Most misstatements affect both a balance sheet and income statement account. Therefore auditors must design the audit to find the smallest misstatement that would influence users of the financial statements. Reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free of material misstatements cannot be provided unless the audit is designed to detect the smallest misstatement that would influence users. d) Why is the risk of management fraud considered when determining tolerable misstatement The......

Words: 761 - Pages: 4

5.1 Study Case Panera Bread

...different type of business with different problems from those of firms run by an owner manager. Small businesses are imitative in nature, with most small firms doing what other firms do, with only slight variations. But when we think about the people who start firms for the first time, the situations they face are situations of novelty. The purpose of a small business is to create and keep customer and to generate profit. On the other hand, since1995, small businesses have generated 64 percent of new jobs, and paid 44 percent of the total United States private payroll, according to the SBA. Strategic management is owner plans for how the organization will what it's in business to do, how it will compete successfully, and how it will attract and satisfy its customers in order to achieve goals. STEP TO START UP SMALL BUSINESS In order to start a business, we need four elements to come together, which is: Resources Money, product, knowledge That start up business Need. Boundary Creating a place for business -in strategic location and In customer mind Your Small Business Exchange Moving resources, money, products In exchange for money Intention The desire to start business The first step is the individual's commitment to becoming a business owner and get inspired. In preparing a business plan, the entrepreneur must choose the industry and market in which he or she plans to compete. This choice means assessing not only industry conditions and trends but...

Words: 5233 - Pages: 21

Case Study 5.1 Panera Bread

...Q1. How has Panera Bread established a unique position in the restaurant industry? How has this unique position contributed to the firm’s success? Do you think Panera Bread will reach its goal of becoming a leading national brand in the restaurant industry? Why or why not? Panera Bread has established a unique position in the restaurant industry by developing itself with various approaches. First of all, Panera Bread has observed the consumer always wanted good food quality and speed services. This has given the Panera Bread an opportunity to reposition itself by joining the concept of fast food and casual dining category. This category provided the consumer the alternative they wanted by capturing the advantages of the both categories. Besides, with the good timing which became the first mover to this new category also led itself to this favorable position. This new category has made Panera Bread’s position not only unique but also contributed to its success. Panera Bread did a lot of things to distinguish itself from its rivals such as adding specialty food, different menus, catering service, new time suggesting of specialty food and providing inviting neighborly atmosphere. According to the text, Panera Bread serves nearly six million customers a week systemwide and become one of the largest chains. This shows that the unique position has contributed to its success. In my opinion, I think Panera Bread will reach its goal because the company is relying on its......

Words: 309 - Pages: 2

Case Studies 5.1 - 5.2 - 5.3 Ais 4081 Leadership Theory and Practice

...Laurie Baird Case Studies 5.1 - 5.2 - 5.3 AIS 4081 Leadership Theory and Practice February 6, 2013 Case 5.1 Questions: 1) According to the basic assumptions of situational leadership, where would you place the three managers in regard to levels of development in the SLII model? Rick Nakano - D4-level. "Seasoned workers with proven abilities and great devotion to a company would be identified as functioning at the D4 level" (Northouse 103). Beth Edwards - Even though she is a manager - she is a D1. "For example, new employees who are very excited but lack understanding of job requirements would be identified as D1-level employees (Northouse 103). Steve Lynch - D3-level - confident on some counts and very insecure on others aspects of his job. 2) If you were Bruce would you act the same toward each of the three managers? I would handle each manager differently on certain aspects. When you know their leadership abilities you need to nurture the lacking characteristics and build them up. According to the descriptions in the case, there are definitely differences in their capabilities. As the owner of the company, being aware of the differences will help to achieve positive results for the company. 3) Which conference would be the hardest for you, and which would be the easiest? Why? The conference with Beth Edwards would be exceptionally difficult. She has an incredible spirit but lacks knowledge. She must be either taught very quickly the......

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Case 5.1

...Camille Copeland MGMT 631: Management & Organization Behavior Case 5.1 3/19/2015 The case begins by stating “rigid rankings hinder the teamwork and risk-taking necessary for innovation (Ivancevich, Konopaske, Matteson, 2011).” That being said many companies used the described ranking systems to evaluate their employees, putting them against each other and some even lead to firing of low performers. A performance review is supposed to be a time to reflect on how an employee has or has not fulfilled the expectations of the manager and the individual goals that were set. In this case analysis, the technique of rank of employees by General electrical (G.E.) and Yahoo! are looked at. Both companies have used ranking scales and are now looking for a more innovative style to rank employees but still foster a motivational atmosphere. In the past, G.E. has used a 20/70/10 split (top 20 percent, the middle 70 percent, and the low-performing 10 percent) which required managers to place employees into one of the three groups hence comparing employees against one another (Ivancevich, Konopaske, Matteson, 2011). The managers rank employees against each other and then use the ranking to determine who receives a raise, bonus, promotions, and sometimes who gets fired. Forced ranking allows the top-ranked employees to be rewarded for their hard work. Yahoo! used a similar ranking system but compared employees against a standard, not against each other (Ivancevich et al., 2011). The......

Words: 936 - Pages: 4

Case Study: the First Appraisal Interview

...CASE STUDY: THE FIRST APPRAISAL INTERVIEW Name: Benjamin Van de Walle Lecturer: Ms. Mai Kim Thoa Course: Managerial Skills & Leadership – KS 402DE02 1. What do you think of the boss’s ratings and his defense of them? * * He gives Sandy an average rate for every single point. She doesn’t know if this is a good or a bad rate. He is not fair cause’ he bases his ratings on one single point, namely the wine service and generalizes this for the other points. In my opinion his comments are not constructive and well-intentioned. * * He focuses his defense only on her less developed skills and doesn’t mention her good skills. Also his defense is very flat. With that I mean that he doesn’t give any specific and descriptive feedback. He doesn’t define the performance problem, doesn’t makes his standards clear and he doesn’t work with the employee to set goals for improvement. The boss focuses on the person and not on the behavior, it’s personally hurtful. * 2. How do you think Sandy feels? Will she be motivated to improve? Is it enough to know you are not going to lose your job? * * Sandy went to the appraisal interview with confidence. But I think she lost her confidence after the interview. Due to the average score she doesn’t know where and how to improve. * * By not focusing on employees needs in a highly effective way, the employees will not be motivated. He does nothing to support Sandy, whereby she also loses her......

Words: 597 - Pages: 3

Journal for Case Study 5.1

...profile and become what I want in the future. Some stuff takes time and sometimes the perfect opportunity is right there infront of you. After doing the assessment it showed I had a high career vision and path. I believe this is correct, I have a plan of what I want to do with my life. If anyone tries to get into my way I will cut that person out of my life and carry on with what I really want to do. Some day I will own my business and I will be successful, at this point in time I am only working towards that dream. Chapter 6 Chapter 6 will be covering strategic thinking. I believe my downfall is I try to see the best possible outcome for everyone and that may or may not hinder the outcomes. I have to start thinking for the company first and not feelings. After doing the assessment it showed I have a medium strategic thinking process. I need to plan things out more, think of all outcomes and take action. If the action harms someone it may still be necessary to do so. My downfall and forever will be my downfall I want to please everyone no matter what. I have to become selfish. Chapter 7 After slightly glancing over chapter 7 I saw it was briefly about decision making skills as an individual and as a group. Individual decision making skills are very important because it can not only affect you but also your group if you are working at a group task. If you are looking to make the best of both worlds you need to have set steps and thought processes to benefit either......

Words: 2327 - Pages: 10

Introduction to Market Research: First Direct Case Study

...research and how these methods have been used to make marketing decisions for first direct. Carrying on from this I will be suggesting how different methods are appropriate to enable first direct to revitalise its brand relaunch and evaluating the businesses market research. Marketing is a management process which is responsible for identifying, anticipating and satisfying consumer requirements profitably. To satisfy consumer needs is to make sure the consumer gets what they want. You do this through market research. The first stage of market research is to plan it also called the ‘MR process; .Define the problem .Define research objectives .Choose data sources .Choose research methods .Set budgets and deadlines .Undertake research .Analysis and evaluate Choosing the research is what I am focusing on today. There are four main sources of research, qualitative, quantitative, primary and secondary. Primary research Primary research is new information obtained by an organisation first hand from using their own resources and collecting their own data to answer specific issues or questions. The method can involve observation, experimentations, surveys, focus groups, interviews, field trials and panels. Surveys are one of the most frequently used methods of market research, there are four common ways of conducting a survey, via post, email, face to face and over the phone. The survey allows a careful study of a specific topic questioning consumers and gaining their opinion,......

Words: 2568 - Pages: 11

Audit Case

...ISSUES IN ACCOUNTING EDUCATION Vol. 18, No. 3 August 2003 pp. 275-290   Designing Audit Procedures When Evidence Is Electronic: The Case of e-Ticket Travel Revenue   A. Faye Borthick and Jack E. Kiger   ABSTRACT: The objective of the Fly Airline case is for you to learn to develop audit procedures in a context, e-ticket revenue, in which most of the evidence is available electronically, and in which many tests of controls and substantive tests can be performed using data stored in electronic form. In sequence, you will identify controls and their objectives, match controls to financial statement assertions for revenue, develop tests of controls, develop substantive tests for each assertion, and organize audit procedures into an effective and efficient audit program.   Keywords: auditing; e-ticket revenue; collaborative learning; electronic evidence; internal control; monitoring; systems expertise for auditing.   OVERVIEW ly Airline's revenue generation begins when a customer selects a flight for a specific date and time. The process is similar whether a ticket agent or the customer interacts with the system to make the reservation. If the customer is paying with a credit card, the system validates the credit card number the customer presents for billing before making the reservation. When it obtains approval of the credit charge (electronically, from the card issuer), the system records the charge and other details of the reservation. The......

Words: 5672 - Pages: 23

Flashpoint eVOLV 200 R2 TTL Pocket Flash with Barndoor Kit (Godox AD200) #EV-200 | Westworld - Season 1 COMPLETE | Telefoni