Free Essay

Beowulf vs 13th Warrior

In: English and Literature

Submitted By ljasens1
Words 1025
Pages 5
Beowulf A good hero is a person who has a great talent and uses that talent at the right time, making them a hero. Both the heroes in Beowulf and in 13th Warrior have a skill that they use at the right moment, which separates them from other individuals, making them a hero. Beowulf himself is a man full as brute strength and pure power in order to defeat his foes. Ahmed Ibn Fadlan lacks the strength aspect, unlike Beowulf but has great intellect, which helps him to succeed and become a hero. Beowulf does not think of any enemy as threatening and believe that his strength will not be matched. Ahmed is not strong and has no strength to rely on like Beowulf. What Ahmed does have is intellect, which he uses to replace his absence of strength. The better hero is Beowulf out of the two. It seems that Ahmed would be a better sidekick to Beowulf in he cannot physically do a lot. Ahmed would be able to think of plans and strategies and Beowulf would be able to implement them and make them work. Just as Wiglaf helped Beowulf neither one could defeat the dragon without the other. This would be the case if Ahmed and Beowulf were with each other; they would both be needed in order to accomplish something. Beowulf has strength and knows of it, which is a great benefit to him. He gets confidence knowing that he is extremely strong and gains courage from this. He is not afraid of anything including Grendel who everyone in the story fears. Grendel comes to the land of the Spear-Danes and is confronted by Beowulf. During the confrontation, Grendel gets its arm ripped off by Beowulf and it is hung as a trophy. Grendel runs away and Beowulf has defeated a monster using his strength. Looking at Ahmed’s first interaction with the enemy when they attack at night when the men are pretending to sleep, he is thrown around like a rag doll and fears the “Wendol.” In this moment Ahmed does nothing to help save any of his other companions and is lucky he did not die. This is different from Beowulf in the fact that when Beowulf gets into a confrontation he always comes out on top and does not get thrown around because of his strength unlike Ahmed.
Ahmed does not become effective until he starts to use his own intellect to help him battle. He fixes the sword so that he can lift it and be able to use it; however it is not as big as the other sword which Beowulf could have lifted easily. This strength is seen from Beowulf when he confronts and battles Grendel’s mother. Beowulf is able to pick up the big sword and slay Grendel’s mother avenging his fallen comrades. Ahmed would not have been able to be a hero in this instance because Grendel’s mother was a monster as well as Grendel himself. When Ahmed thought that he was battling a bear monster, he was scared and struggled to fight them. It was not until he saw that they were only men that he became effective and was able to kill them. Beowulf did not care who he was fighting, he always had courage to stand and fight. This cannot be said for Ahmed as he was scared and did not fight until he saw that the bear monsters were only men. Ahmed overthinks everything too much which is another reason why he is not a better hero then Beowulf. Beowulf does not think about going into battle more than once if it is what is required of him. Ahmed however, does not want to go with the warriors to battle the “Wendol” and save the village that is in need of their help. He is worried about who he is fighting and becomes scared because of this. Beowulf only think when he needs, which is very little at first until he is meant to become king and learns from Hrothgar. Beowulf thinks and uses his intellect of what he has when he watches Grendel’s mother fight and take some of his comrades. He watches Grendel’s mother and examines how she fights, giving him an advantage over her when they come in contact with each other. Beowulf does not think about whom he is going to be fighting or how scary they are because he knows he will conquer anything. Beowulf’s strength gives him confidence while Ahmed’s intellect just gives him the ability to learn a language or knowledge about who he is competing against. When Beowulf goes after the dragon when he is older, he states that he will conquer this beast alone and save the people. Ahmed would not be able to defeat the dragon on his own when he was young let alone when he grows older. This is why Beowulf is a greater hero because at this time the people needed to be saved from a dragon and he was able to defend them and save them. If this were Ahmed in Beowulf’s shoes would he be able to defend the people using his intellect or would he need strength to kill the beast like Beowulf did. Beowulf using intellect by bringing armor and protection against the dragon, showing that he has developed some intellect as he grew older. Throughout the whole time Ahmed was fighting at no point did he get straight man power strength. Beowulf is the better hero between the two because he can defend people against any enemy with his strength. Ahmed would make a good assistant or sidekick to a man with strength as he did in the 13th Warrior. Beowulf would sacrifice his life as he did versus the dragon to save his people and Ahmed was afraid to even go to battle. As seen in Beowulf intellect can be developed over time, but becoming a courageous hero is something that you are born with. Beowulf is born a hero and died a hero; Ahmed was in a group of heroes and not physically a hero himself.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...of Honor and Success Throughout the entire text of Beowulf, the accumulation and re-distribution of t reassure serves to have symbolism regarding acts of bravery, honor, success, and reward. Treasure is both gained through the brave battles that Beowulf fights against the three monsters he encounters, and his rewards reflect upon his success and honor in victory. Treasure is also redistributed throughout the text form king to warrior and vice-versa, symbolizing the acknowledgement of honor and reward from one generation to the next. Treasure is viewed in each of the battles as proof of victory and with this proof of success, the holder of such treasure proves that he is worthy and deserving of loyalty from and by brave warriors. After slaying Grendel, Grendel’s mother, and the dragon, treasure is gained and passed along to the next generation, such as when Hrothgar gives gifts to Beowulf, who distributes it among his people, to show and symbolize the potential sacrifices made to gain the treasure, and thus the bravery, honor, success, and reward that the treasure surely represents throughout the text. After Beowulf slays the monster Grendel, King Hrothgar rewards and thanks Beowulf for his efforts by offering him several objects considered treasure. Among the multitude of objects that he presents to Beowulf: “He gave to Beowulf the blade of Healfdene/ a golden war-standard Roberts: 2 as a reward for victory” (Beowulf 1020-1021) Here the word “treasure” is substituted......

Words: 1126 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...* Essay Topic Good vs. Evil. How are the concepts of good and evil presented in Beowulf? Does this reveal anything about Anglo-Saxon society? Beowulf is the greatest surviving Old English poem, an epic that recounts the main events in the life of a legendary hero named Beowulf. Beowulf’s destiny is to fight and conquer the monsters that terrorize the kingdom of the Danes. Many events in Beowulf are directly related to the Bible, making the constant battle between good and evil one of the most important themes. Beowulf is a courageous, strong and loyal warrior. He is brave, and he has self confidence bordering on insanity, but he’s also generous and kind towards others. Beowulf shows that he has confidence when he fights Grendel without weapons. When he defeats Grendel, he demonstrates that men are capable of destroying evil if they wish to do so. Beowulf’s qualities make him the epitome of a hero. “Beowulf emphasizes values that were important to Norse warriors, such as courage, loyalty to one's king and comrades, and honor for those who fight and die bravely. The story emphasizes how fragile life and fame can be. Like any person, Beowulf must find meaning in his world while accepting the fact that he will eventually die. He meets that challenge by facing danger bravely and trusting that the story of his deeds will cause him to live on in the memories of those who hear it.” (from the New Catholic Encyclopedia) Goodness is represented throughout the poem by the......

Words: 930 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...monster went in the night toward Heorot to attack. He believes that the warriors of Heorot are sleeping and that he will be successful. Unfortunately for Grendel, Beowulf was aware of what was going on. Grendel swallows a warrior, and then attempts to reach for Beowulf. Beowulf snatches Grendel's claw and holds on as tightly as he can. Grendel is just imagining being home, but he could not even budge with Beowulf's grip. Eventually he rips from Beowulf's grasp and flees leaving behind his arm. The people had seen the battle because they were awoken by Grendel's screams, but they felt helpless in the situation. Although they did not participate they were still able to praise Beowulf on his victory. Beowulf and the people rejoice over the arm in the light of day. This story symbolizes light and darkness very clearly. Grendel is this dark monster coming to Heorot in the darkest time of the day, while Beowulf is awaiting his arrival in the light, and he is heroic person and the light is always shining upon him. The dark and gruesome battle is happening in the dark, and they rejoice the victory in the light of day. 3 ) Grendel the scary monster went to Heorot in the dark of the night to attack. When he arrived he believed everyone would be in a dark sleep. "Then he stopped, seeing the hall Crowded with sleeping warriors" (line 409-10). He first ate one warrior. "Ripped him apart, cut his body to bits with powerful jaws,......

Words: 768 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Beowulf

...“A Selfish Hero” Many people recognize Beowulf as the hero of Anglo-Saxon times. Judging by his amazing resume of feats and strengths, this is not hard to believe. Beowulf exemplifies the traits of a perfect and valiant hero, or so it seems. However, Beowulf, written by an unknown author, illustrates the great length the character goes through to succeed. Beowulf does anything in his power to prevail, leading him to become a selfish individual. Examining Beowulf's speech, thoughts, and actions, it becomes evident of the selfish hero within. Firstly, Beowulf's speech proves that he would do anything to prevail, illustrating his inflated ego. Although defeated in some battles, Beowulf manages to carry out every mission in order to justify his loses and make himself look successful. Unferth, who attempts to criticize Beowulf’s battles says, "Then winter churned through the water, the waves ran you as they willed, and you struggled seven long nights to survive. And at the end victory was his, not yours” (22;6;248-51). However, upon hearing this, Beowulf accuses Unferth of being drunk in order to make people believe he never understands what he says. "Ah! Unferth, my friend, your face is hot with ale, and your tongue had tried to tell us about Brecca's doings” (22;6;263-65). After hearing this, people are lead to believe Beowulf never takes this criticism seriously, for Unferth‘s drunkenness hazes his rationality. Thus, Beowulf makes Unferth, appear envious, while making......

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...Monster Beowulf perfectly illustrates the characteristics of what it means to be considered a perfect hero. The poem clearly shows his heroism in two completely different eras, Beowulf as a young man and then again when he is much older. This is shown through battles of three monsters, Grendel, Grendel’s Mother, and the dragon; each is progressively more difficult than the last. But as the poem digresses it is easy to see that the biggest monster that Beowulf fights is himself. As a young man, Beowulf is an extremely successful warrior, shown by his ginormous wins of both bravery and strength. He also exemplifies the characteristics of loyalty, respect and most importantly pride. When the poem begins, Beowulf shows little maturity as he has always had his inhuman powers. The great king Hrothgar quickly becomes a father like figure to Beowulf and begins to give wisdom about how to be a great king. This foreshadows the second half of the poem, his impressive past as a undefeated warrior has in some ways prepared Beowulf to take claim of the throne. Years later the Geat King Hygelac dies, this is important because Beowulf doesn’t simply take the throne in which he has rightfully earned instead he chooses to support Hygelac’s son as he is whom should be the king. This act of respect only further proves his characteristics as a hero. Beowulf progresses throughout the poem from a very unrealistic portrayal of a hero to an extremely realistic man. For his first battle Beowulf......

Words: 1551 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...Beowulf Essay To be a hero in Anglo-Saxon literature and culture one must be a warrior. In the Anglo- Saxon culture a hero had to be intelligent, valorous, prideful and most importantly strong. Fighting for glory and fighting for his people until death was the duty of a hero. The hero had to be willing to face these odds and Beowulf portrayed this. Beowulf is the perfect example of an epic hero because of his prideful actions and willingness to take on fighting the strongest monster and the other hard deeds. "The seafarers used to say, I remember, who took our gifts to the great people in token of friendship-that is fighting man in his hands grasp had the strength of thirty other men. I am thinking that the Holy God, as a grace to us Danes in the West, has directed him here against Grendel’s oppression. Thus good man shall be offered treasures in return for his courage. " (Line 377) Strength is essential to be being an Anglo-Saxon hero. In these lines we can see Beowulf has massive strength if he has strength of thirty men in his arms. "I have not in my life set eyes on a man with more might in his frame than this helmed lord. He's no hall fellow dressed in fine armor, or his face belies him; he has a head of a hero." ( Lines 247) It is clear that physical appearance is essential to being a hero because it is important that you look the part. Even if Beowulf was not the greatest warrior it is always best to act and look the part so he could give the people hope.......

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...The epic poem Beowulf is one of the most important Anglo-Saxon literary works and it should be fairly easy to make a blockbuster movie out of this story. It contains all the elements of a Hollywood movie; it has a strong handsome leading man, plenty of battles, and let’s not forget about the mystical dragon. So with all this adventure I figured that the movie would fall in line with the poem but you could imagine my surprise while watching to see just how far it strayed away from the original. As I was watching the movie I noticed little differences, like the characters are not how they were described in the book nor was the setting adequate enough to portray how grand Heorot really was but for the most part the story line was followed. The story started to change the night that Grendel was introduced. The movie showed Grendel as a more human form of a monster who started attacking Heorot because the villagers were making too much noise. I didn’t remember reading that Grendel was sensitive to noise or that he attacked the village while they were celebrating. As the movie progresses it tells us that Hrothgar is Grendel’s father because he was seduced by Grendel’s mother. The poem never even hinted of a love affair between Grendel’s mother and anyone so this part of the movie was a stretch. This change in the plot makes the way the characters are portrayed seem completely different and makes it harder to connect them with their original character’s personalities in the poem.......

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Beowulf

... Danish  warriors  and  sometimes  even  eating  them.  Hrothgar  was  a  great  warrior   in  his  time,  but  now  he's  an  old  king  and  can't  seem  to  protect  his  people.  Fortunately,   a  young  Geat  warrior  named  Beowulf  travels  to  Heorot  Hall  from  his  own  lands   overseas  to  lend  a  helping  hand  – literally. After  explaining  that  he  owes  Hrothgar  a  favor  because  Hrothgar  helped  out  his   father,  Beowulf  offers  to  fight  Grendel  himself.  King  Hrothgar  gratefully  accepts  his   offer.  The  next  time  Grendel  attacks  Heorot  Hall,  Beowulf  is  waiting  for  him.  Choosing   to  fight  Grendel  in  hand-­‐to-­‐hand  combat,  Beowulf  wrestles  the  demon  into   submission  and  eventually  tears  off  his  arm  at  the  shoulder.  Mortally  wounded,   Grendel  flees  into  the  wilderness  and  dies.  Beowulf,  Hrothgar,  and  their  followers   throw  a  wild  party  to  celebrate.   Hrothgar  also  gives  Beowulf  many  presents  and   treasures  to  reward  him  for  his  heroic  defeat  of  the  demon. Unfortunately,  Grendel  has  an  overprotective  mother  who  decides  to  avenge  her  son.   While  all  the  warriors  are  sleeping  off  the  party,  she  attacks  Heorot  Hall.  But  when  the   warriors  wake  up,  she  panics  and  flees  back  to  her  lair,  a  cave  underneath  a  nearby   lake. Beowulf,  his  Geatish  warriors,  and  some  of  Hrothgar's  Danish  warriors  track  her  there.   Beowulf  dives......

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Character Analysis: Beowulf vs Odysseus

...Wallace Literature 201 Beowulf- Character Analysis For this analysis I chose to contrast Beowulf with The Odyssey’s, Odysseus. Both of the protagonists in these stories have very similar traits and cultural ideals, while maintaining subtle differences. They are both strong and intelligent. They are both boastful, but never without just reason. They are both an ideal representation of the attributes that were praised by their individual societies. However, there are many notable differences in their modus operandi. One of the most notable being their libidos, or absence of. Odysseus was a great leader whose shrewd intellect enabled the Greeks to defeat the Trojans in the war. Beowulf was known to be a great warrior and acute thinker to his fellow Geats and proved to be just as shrewd in assisting the Danes. At the very beginning of the story of Beowulf we are immediately introduced to a shared ideal amongst the Germanic and Greek culture; the importance of family lineage. Much like it is vital for the author to explain the back story of Hrothgar’s lineage and often times refer to Beowulf as “son of Ecgtheow”, it is also vital for Odysseus to give his father’s name when confessing himself to Polyphemus and the loyalty Telemachus shows to his father. One area of difference between the two would be whether are not they exhibit values of “fair-fighting”. While they were both very witty and intelligent, their tactics for using it differed slightly. Beowulf was a much more......

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Beowulf Essay

...Light vs. Dark In the epic poem Beowulf, a battle between light and dark arises throughout Heorot, and even though it looked as if darkness had fallen over society, light broke through the darkness, ultimately shining back onto civilization. This darkness that has fallen over Heorot follows Grendel, the monster from Hell, with every step he takes. Only coming out at night to terrorize the people, this darkness seems to be unbeatable, and all hope seems lost. But, Beowulf, a warrior who “swam in the blackness of night, hunting monsters out of the ocean, and killing them one by one” (Beowulf 417-422) has come to Heorot with the intention of driving out this darkness. This epic battle that is soon to take place will help to illuminate the difference between the light of Heorot and the darkness of Grendel. Leading up to the battle Heorot looks to be elegant and shining with beauty, but once Grendel and darkness enter into the halls, all of this goes away, and turns dark. Beowulf is called to the rescue, and brings with him the light that will ultimately defeat Grendel, and show that light will defeat darkness in the darkest times. As the light begins to fade away in the halls of Heorot, Grendel arises from is lair and uses the darkness to create a fear of death. While the night sky is over-head, the soldiers are unable to see what lurks in the shadows, and the “{soldiers} sworn to stay after dark and stem that horror with a sweep of their swords. And then, in the morning,......

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Beowulf

... In the epic poem of Beowulf, there are many events where supernatural strength is used by not only Beowulf himself, but as well as Grendel, Grendel’s mother, and a few other characters throughout the poem. The story starts off with the battle with Grendel, and both Beowulf and Grendel have supernatural strength, and so does Grendel’s mother. Beowulf and Grendel are both larger than life and they are both strong, and they have supernatural strength. In this poem, Beowulf does what is best for his people. He defends them and he eventually becomes king and is praised very frequently for his heroic duties. That is mainly what makes Beowulf larger than life, or what some may call famous. He takes care of his people and in exchange they take care of him. Grendel is an enormous, creature that was a decedent of Kane and he had been holding Denmark hostage for 12 years before Beowulf arrived. years. His demeanor is what really made him an outsider and people didn’t accept him. Beowulf’s first battle was with Grendel. The twelve foot beast rudely interrupted a celebration in the Hall that King Hrothgar had built for his people to come and fellowship with each other. Grendel was well known for his terrorism in many different situations. Beowulf’s warriors couldn’t harm the beast because Grendel had put a curse against all weapons to harm him. That being, Beowulf ripped off Grendel’s arm which was the only way to defeat him. King Hrothgar was pleased that Beowulf had defeated Grendel......

Words: 621 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...(181-182) for help. (Confused about religion in Beowulf? Check out what we have to say about religion in the "Symbols, Imagery, Allegory" section.) • Despite all the good advice, Hrothgar and his followers can't defeat Grendel, and he keeps killing the Danes in the darkness of night. • Across the water from the Danes in Geatland (today part of Sweden), the mightiest warrior on earth, a follower of King Hygelac, decides that he will travel to the Spear-Danes and help King Hrothgar defeat Grendel. He orders that a boat be made ready. • Everyone knows better than to argue with this warrior or try to stop him. Instead, they help him get ready. They enlist fourteen other warriors to accompany him. • Loading their ship with weapons, the mysterious hero and his followers set sail. After a day at sea, they come to the Danish coast, where they thank God for their easy passage. • The Danish warrior on lookout duty rides down to the shore to find out who the new warriors are and whether they're on a mission of peace or of war. He issues a formal challenge to the Geats to explain who they are and why they've come, and he notices how noble and mighty the mysterious hero looks. • The warrior explains that he is a Geat, a follower of King Hygelac, and the son of a noble and famous warlord named Ecgtheow. He explains that the Geats haven't come to fight the Danes, but to help fight the demonic enemy of the Danes. • The lookout believes the warrior and allows him to pass; he even......

Words: 2117 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Arthur vs Beowulf

...viciously gallant epic Beowulf, Steve Baron’s capricious film Merlin, and Niccolo Machiavelli’s enlightening treatise The Prince all portray the struggle between good and evil, teach morals, and convey what it takes to be a superior king. Merlin has successfully brought up King Arthur to become a virtuous man and a worthy king who is exceptionally capable of fulfilling Machiavelli’s guidelines. For example, Machiavelli states in “Concerning Things for Which Men, and Especially Princes, are Blamed” from The Prince that “…a man who wishes to act entirely up to his professions of virtue soon meets with what destroys him among so much that is evil.” Merlin taught Arthur integrity and goodness. King Arthur takes this wisdom to build the perfect kingdom “devoted to peace and charity” (Merlin). Arthur is the first king without egocentric intentions. Even in his last battle, King Arthur puts his morals before his own life. His desolation proves his righteousness. Rather than leaving his people afraid, his death leaves his people with hope of a better place and rebirth. In life and death, King Arthur ruled his nation. Beowulf brought riches to his people, defended his people, and essentially devoted his life to his people, which made him an ideal prince in the eyes of Machiavelli. For instance, Machiavelli states in The Prince that a ruler should “have no other aim or thought, nor select anything else for his study, than war and its rules and discipline.” In Beowulf, war is......

Words: 717 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...Chantel Carter History 4330 Beowulf: An Anglo-Saxon Hero Every culture has its heroes. In the poem Beowulf, the Anglo-Saxon view of a hero is revealed. In Anglo-Saxon culture, to be a hero was to be a warrior. This is due to the fact that they derived from a Germanic culture. A hero had to be strong and skillful, courageous, and loyal. At the same time they also had to be generous and humble. Beowulf’s courageous and respectable qualities depict the Anglo-Saxon’s view of a hero during that time. In addition, the respect the characters show for their kings illustrate the high esteem in which the Anglo-Saxons held their kings. These examples also show the importance of gaining honor in this culture. The characteristics of Beowulf, the respect held for their kings, and the importance of honor provide a glimpse into the Anglo-Saxon society. One of Beowulf’s characteristics that are shown early on in the poem is his strength. When he arrives in the land of Dane, he is described as having “the strength of thirty in his mighty hand-grip.”1 Beowulf’s first challenge is to rid the land of the monster Grendel. He decides to make it more than just a simple task of slaying the monster when he declares that it will be a hand-to-hand fight. I have heard it said this evil monster in his wild recklessness scorns all weapons. I therefore decline, that Hygelac my lord may be pleased to the heart, to take any sword or broad-braced shield, yellow war-wood, into this combat, but with......

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Beowulf

...Beowulf’s Wisdom as a Warrior Beowulf, an epic tale from the Anglo-Saxon era, depicts a hero that goes by the name Beowulf. Beowulf is a Geatish warrior who lives to later on becomes a king. On this journey from a young warrior of the Geatish nation, to a king amongst the people, Beowulf experienced many battles and ended up victorious to his last breath. Out of the many battles Beowulf had, three specific battles stand out to show how Beowulf evolved as a warrior. These battles are; the battle with Grendel, the battle with Grendel’s mother, and the battle with a dragon. The progress achieved in each battle proved to be constructive to his wisdom as a warrior. The first battle took place in the land of the Danes with, “This grim spirit called Grendel, / mighty stalker of the marches,” (Beowulf 103-104). Grendel terrorized the mead hall named “Heorot.” This terrorizing of the mead hall, by Grendel, took place for twelve long winters in the Danish land. Word of this terrorizing reached the ears of Beowulf which caused him and his army to travel to land of the Danes. Grendel’s terror consisted of sneaking upon sleeping soldiers in the mead hall and fulfilling his bloodlust and hatred by slaying the Danish soldiers. As said before this slaying took place for twelve winters. At this point, Beowulf is a young and naïve soldier. This is shown by his battle with the monster Grendel. Instead of going into battle with armor, weapons, and anything else that would give Beowulf the......

Words: 1397 - Pages: 6

Tech Learning November 2011 Reup | Universal soldier Day of recko.. DVDRIP | Patrick Stewart